Modern living room with a sofa and floor-to-ceiling windows

Home · Blog · New construction

Builder incentives vs. price cuts: which saves you more?

Builders often offer a choice: money off the price, or the same amount toward closing costs or a lower interest rate. Here’s how to tell which saves you more.

An example

Say you’re buying a $450,000 home with 5% down, at a 6.5% rate. The builder offers $20,000 either way. These numbers are rough illustrations, not quotes.

  • $20,000 off the price: your principal and interest drops by about $120 a month. Your property taxes are also lower, by roughly $30 a month at a 2% tax rate.
  • $20,000 toward a permanent rate buydown: that might lower the rate by about 1 percentage point, depending on the lender. At 5.5%, principal and interest drops by about $275 a month.

In this example, the buydown saves more each month.

When the price cut wins

  • If you might sell or refinance within a few years. The buydown’s savings stop when the loan ends. A lower price keeps paying off.
  • Lower taxes for years. Your purchase price affects your appraised value.
  • Less to borrow. A lower price also lowers mortgage insurance and the loan amount.

Watch for these

  • Temporary buydowns, like a 2-1 buydown, lower the rate only for the first year or two.
  • Preferred lender requirements. Most incentives require the builder’s lender. Compare its full Loan Estimate with an outside lender.
  • Design center credits only help if you would have bought those upgrades anyway.

Run your own numbers

I ask builders for every option in writing, then compare them with you and your lender: monthly payment, cash to close and the total cost over the years you expect to stay.

General information, not legal, tax or lending advice. Programs, rates and limits change, so confirm the details for your situation with the right professional.

Shopping new homes?

Bring me on your first builder visit. In most cases the builder pays my fee.